Deliberationv4.6.1

Is passing an ignored input to a Terraform data source a breaking change?

Question, reviewed by the architect expert on codex, gemini, grok and or:glm-5-3-flashx. It follows up terraform-aws-modules/terraform-aws-eventbridge/pull/212.

unresolved after 5 rounds

Recovered from the logs of a run on 2026-11-02 on Deliberation 4.0.0, run 0235dc27, tool consensus-step. Reviewer text is verbatim, so it can disagree with itself and with the verdict line the engine read.

The prompt

Question

Decide the severity band in a Terraform module PR reviewer (Check G, rule compat.expression-behaviour-changed) for a change that makes an input the module previously IGNORED on one code path take effect there.

Sent to every reviewer

Full text, verbatim (2,658 characters)
Decide the severity band in a Terraform module PR reviewer (Check G, rule compat.expression-behaviour-changed) for a change that makes an input the module previously IGNORED on one code path take effect there.

Current Severity rule (check-g-behaviour.md): CRITICAL when a value the variable's type accepts and its description allows now plans differently and the change does not declare a break; HIGH when it declares the break with no migration path; LOW when the only inputs affected are ones the provider rejects or the description rules out (a value the module silently dropped now errors). Verdict ladder: rule 0 = any CRITICAL whose CRITICAL/HIGH are all compat.* -> "hold for next major" (COMMENT); HIGH/MEDIUM -> block (REQUEST_CHANGES, rules 1/2/6); LOW only -> approve with nits (COMMENT). The interface rules of Check A own changed inputs/outputs/types/defaults/addresses; this rule covers same interface, different behaviour.

Motivating case: terraform-aws-modules/terraform-aws-eventbridge#212 "fix: Add region to aws_cloudwatch_event_bus data source". With create_bus = false, the module looked up an existing bus via a data source that ignored var.region (read in the provider's region), while the module's other resources already used var.region. The PR adds region = var.region to the data source. Callers with region = null see no change; callers who set region to another region now read the bus in that region, so derived ARNs change. Maintainers merged it as a patch fix. Two reviewer runs of the same diff rated it CRITICAL (-> hold for next major) and then LOW, because no rule covers this case.

Options:
A) New LOW band: when the only callers affected set an input the base ignored on that path, and the head gives it the effect its name and description state (the same effect it already has on the module's other resources), rate LOW; summary names the input, path and observable change and asks for a release note. No major release.
B) Same condition, MEDIUM (blocks with REQUEST_CHANGES until the description states the change for those callers; once stated, LOW).
C) Keep CRITICAL (any caller-observable change for an allowed value is a break), add only guidance that the summary call it a fix of an ignored input.
D) Other.

Constraints: no provider facts from memory; the band must be decidable by the reviewer from the code diff and the variable's description; it must not open a loophole where any behaviour change is relabelled a 'fix' to dodge CRITICAL (e.g. require the input to already apply elsewhere in the module, or its description to promise the effect). Give the exact condition wording you would put in the rule.

Round history

Round history
RoundBlind verdictReviewersAfter adjudicationOutcome
Round 1 2m 34sREQUEST CHANGEScodex REQUEST CHANGES[2]gemini REQUEST CHANGES[3]grok REQUEST CHANGES[3]or:glm-5-3-flashx APPROVE[3]REQUEST CHANGES revisedNot converged, 1 of 4 approved
Round 2 3m 19sREQUEST CHANGEScodex REQUEST CHANGES[1]gemini APPROVEgrok REQUEST CHANGES[4]or:glm-5-3-flashx APPROVE[2]REQUEST CHANGES revisedNot converged, 2 of 4 approved
Round 3 3m 50sREQUEST CHANGEScodex REQUEST CHANGES[1]gemini APPROVEgrok REQUEST CHANGES[5]or:glm-5-3-flashx REQUEST CHANGES[2]REQUEST CHANGES revisedNot converged, 1 of 4 approved
Round 4 3m 30sAPPROVEcodex REQUEST CHANGES[2]gemini REQUEST CHANGES[4]grok REQUEST CHANGES[4]or:glm-5-3-flashx APPROVEREQUEST CHANGES revisedNot converged, 1 of 4 approved
Round 5 7m 18sAPPROVEcodex REQUEST CHANGES[2]gemini APPROVEgrok REQUEST CHANGES[4]or:glm-5-3-flashx APPROVEREQUEST CHANGES revisedNot converged, 2 of 4 approved

Round 1

Blind verdict. Before any reviewer answered, the host agent recorded REQUEST CHANGES with 2 issues of its own: pick A (LOW, no major), anchored on the input already taking that effect elsewhere at the base, or its description naming the path, with default callers unchanged; anything short of that stays CRITICAL.

  • codex REQUEST CHANGESgpt-6.1-sol, 2 issues, 1m 25s

    The recording holds no summary or response text for this answer.

  • gemini REQUEST CHANGESgemini-3.8-flash-high, 3 issues, 2m 21s

    The recording holds no summary or response text for this answer.

  • grok REQUEST CHANGESgrok-4.7, 3 issues, 2m 33s

    The recording holds no summary or response text for this answer.

  • or:glm-5-3-flashx APPROVEz-ai/glm-5.3-flashx, 3 issues, 15s

    The recording holds no summary or response text for this answer.

Round 1 rulings: every issue, with the reason the host agent wrote
IssueRaised byRulingReason
correctness Option A needs a code-checkable anchor and default invariancehost agentacceptRaised also by gemini, grok and glm; folded into conditions 3 and 4.
ambiguity Say what the LOW finding asks for and what applies when the anchor failshost agentacceptRelease-note ask and fallback to CRITICAL/HIGH written into the rule.
ambiguity Promise must exist at the base revision and cover the path; head-only docs do not countcodexacceptCondition 3 reads the base description only; condition 1 requires the description unchanged.
ops Use MEDIUM until the PR description discloses affected callerscodexdismissBlocking a fix with REQUEST_CHANGES over release-note text puts a process ask into the severity scale; grok also argues B is out of scope for Check G. The LOW finding still lists the ask, and a false 'no change' claim stays judged by the existing claim rules.
correctness No default-value invariance: wiring a variable with a non-null default changes callers who omitted itgeminiacceptCondition 4: at the variable's default the head expression yields what the base did, or null.
ambiguity Phrase via module input values, not external callersgeminiacceptConditions rewritten over the variable's values and the two revisions' code.
scope 'Applies to other resources' excludes single-resource modulesgeminiacceptCondition 3 is an OR: the base description naming the path or saying it applies to every resource is enough.
correctness Null vs omit equivalence and no precedence over CRITICALgrokacceptNull as an unset argument is a Terraform language rule, not a provider fact; stated in condition 4. Precedence sentence added: the band is decided before CRITICAL.
ambiguity Matching name or vague description must not satisfy the anchor; base description must be unchanged and state the effectgrokacceptAnchor is the same variable setting the same argument at the base, or a base description that names the path or every resource; description unchanged per condition 1.
scope Option B is changelog text owned elsewhere; Option C adds no bandgrokacceptAgreed; neither B nor C is chosen.
ambiguity CRITICAL and LOW overlap; add precedenceor:glm-5-3-flashxacceptSame as grok's precedence point; added.
correctness Require the same variable honoured on a comparable pathor:glm-5-3-flashxacceptCondition 3 requires the same variable on the same provider argument.
ops No regression example for the motivating PRor:glm-5-3-flashxacceptA worked example for the case is added beside the subnet-ids example, and the reviewer index test checks the band's wording.

Why the round closed this way. codex, gemini and grok voted REQUEST_CHANGES and openrouter:glm-5-3-flashx voted APPROVE. The host accepted 12 issues and dismissed codex's call for a blocking MEDIUM band, then revised the plan to option A with four code-checkable conditions.

revision Chose A with four code-checkable conditions (unchanged interface, newly reached path, base anchor, default invariance), precedence before CRITICAL, fallback, release-note ask, worked example; rejected B and C.

Round 2

Blind verdict. Before any reviewer answered, the host agent recorded REQUEST CHANGES with 1 issue of its own: sound band; tighten condition 4 so null counts as unchanged only where the base left the argument unset.

  • codex REQUEST CHANGESgpt-6.1-sol, 1 issue, 1m 13s

    The recording holds no summary or response text for this answer.

  • gemini APPROVEgemini-3.8-flash-high, 0 issues, 3m 19s

    The recording holds no summary or response text for this answer.

  • grok REQUEST CHANGESgrok-4.7, 4 issues, 3m 17s

    The recording holds no summary or response text for this answer.

  • or:glm-5-3-flashx APPROVEz-ai/glm-5.3-flashx, 2 issues, 10s

    The recording holds no summary or response text for this answer.

Round 2 rulings: every issue, with the reason the host agent wrote
IssueRaised byRulingReason
correctness Condition 4 null shortcut wrong when base argument was non-nullhost agentacceptAlso raised by codex and grok; null counts only where the base left the argument unset or null, and a variable with no default fails the band.
correctness Restrict null shortcut; require equivalent arguments across otherwise identical inputscodexacceptCovered by the tightened condition 4 plus grok's new condition that the head expression reads only this variable.
correctness Null matches only an omitted or null base argument; no default fails the bandgrokacceptSame as above; written into condition 4.
correctness Head expression must read only this variable, or locals that read only itgrokacceptOtherwise another input could change the plan for default calls; added to condition 2.
ambiguity Define changed path, 'the way', the description arm; 'every resource' excludes data sourcesgrokacceptPath is the argument's address (block address plus argument name); 'the way' is the same expression; the description arm needs the block type, its address or 'every resource and data source' in the base text.
ops New sentences must be recorded in the sentence record the index test enforcesgrokacceptThe change adds '+' lines to tests/reviewer-index-sentences.txt for every new sentence of check-g-behaviour.md.
ambiguity Condition 1 depends on Check A's outputor:glm-5-3-flashxacceptCondition 1 now reads the diff directly: no change to the variable's type, default or description.
correctness Worked example claims derived ARNs follow without evidenceor:glm-5-3-flashxacceptExample summary limited to what the conditions show: the data source now reads the bus in that region.

Why the round closed this way. codex and grok voted REQUEST_CHANGES; gemini and openrouter:glm-5-3-flashx approved. The host accepted all 8 issues and revised the conditions.

revision Condition 4 null only where base left the argument unset; head expression reads only the variable; path, 'same expression' and description arm defined; condition 1 reads the diff directly; example summary trimmed; sentence record update named.

Round 3

Blind verdict. Before any reviewer answered, the host agent recorded REQUEST CHANGES with 1 issue of its own: conditions 1-4 are decidable and close the loophole; turn 5 into a scope sentence and the band is ready.

  • codex REQUEST CHANGESgpt-6.1-sol, 1 issue, 2m 56s

    The recording holds no summary or response text for this answer.

  • gemini APPROVEgemini-3.8-flash-high, 0 issues, 2m 19s

    The recording holds no summary or response text for this answer.

  • grok REQUEST CHANGESgrok-4.7, 5 issues, 3m 49s

    The recording holds no summary or response text for this answer.

  • or:glm-5-3-flashx REQUEST CHANGESz-ai/glm-5.3-flashx, 2 issues, 9s

    The recording holds no summary or response text for this answer.

Round 3 rulings: every issue, with the reason the host agent wrote
IssueRaised byRulingReason
ambiguity Condition 5 undecidable; replace with a scope sentencehost agentacceptGrok raised the same; condition 5 removed, scope sentence added.
correctness Explicit unknown inputs equal to the default can still change plans (deferred data reads)codexacceptGuarantee narrowed to 'only module calls that set the variable plan differently', whatever value they pass; the summary names a deferred data read when the block is a data source.
correctness Block must exist at base with unchanged count, for_each and dynamic conditionsgrokacceptAdded as condition 1.
correctness Head expression may be any function of the variable; effect not testedgrokacceptHead expression must be the bare variable reference, or the anchor's expression text.
correctness Block type anchor ambiguous when resource and data source share a type; exclude child modulesgrokacceptDescription arm needs the block's full address or an explicit every-resource-and-data-source statement; anchors are blocks of the same module, never a child module.
ambiguity 'Same expression' has no comparison rule; condition 5 keyed off hunksgrokacceptSame expression means identical text once whitespace is ignored; condition 5 removed.
correctness Fallback drops the existing provider-rejected LOW band; claims false for gated blocks and mixed diffsgrokacceptFallback now 'the other bands apply as written'; gating fixed by condition 1; the band rates this one argument only.
correctness Condition 4 undecidable when the base argument was another input's expressionor:glm-5-3-flashxacceptCondition 4 now: the base argument is absent or literal null, and the variable's default is null.
ambiguity Anchor block with count/for_each or in a child moduleor:glm-5-3-flashxacceptAnchor is any block of the same module, expanded or not, whose argument has the same expression; child-module blocks never anchor.

Why the round closed this way. codex, grok and openrouter:glm-5-3-flashx voted REQUEST_CHANGES; gemini approved. The host accepted all 9 issues and revised the conditions.

revision Block must exist unchanged at base; base argument absent or null and variable default null; head expression bare reference or anchor text; anchors same-module only, description arm needs full address; same expression = identical text ignoring whitespace; condition 5 replaced by scope sentence; guarantee narrowed to calls that set the variable; fallback keeps all other bands.

Round 4

Blind verdict. Before any reviewer answered, the host agent recorded APPROVE: every condition is now decidable from code and closes the relabelling loophole; a non-blocking wording tweak is that the condition 4 anchor should say a resource or data block, so a module call block does not count.

  • codex REQUEST CHANGESgpt-6.1-sol, 2 issues, 1m 17s

    The recording holds no summary or response text for this answer.

  • gemini REQUEST CHANGESgemini-3.8-flash-high, 4 issues, 3m 28s

    The recording holds no summary or response text for this answer.

  • grok REQUEST CHANGESgrok-4.7, 4 issues, 3m 29s

    The recording holds no summary or response text for this answer.

  • or:glm-5-3-flashx APPROVEz-ai/glm-5.3-flashx, 0 issues, 12s

    The recording holds no summary or response text for this answer.

Round 4 rulings: every issue, with the reason the host agent wrote
IssueRaised byRulingReason
correctness Anchor expressions like coalesce(var.x, literal) break default invariance; require bare variable referencescodexacceptRaised by codex, gemini and grok; head and anchor must both be the bare reference var.<name>.
correctness Whitespace-insensitive text match can equate different expressionscodexacceptRemoved with the bare-reference rule; no expression comparison remains.
correctness Arbitrary anchor expressions may be non-null when the variable is unsetgeminiacceptSame as the bare-reference fix.
ambiguity Condition 5 is still counted as a conditiongeminiacceptNow four conditions; the null-is-unset sentence is the reason that follows them.
correctness Worked example summary omits the block addressgeminiacceptSummary now names data.aws_cloudwatch_event_bus.this.
ambiguity Dynamic block wording confuses a top-level block with nested onesgeminiacceptThe argument must be a direct argument of a resource or data block; dynamic wording dropped.
correctness Head may copy a non-null anchor expression; require bare referencegrokacceptSame as the bare-reference fix.
correctness Null-is-unset does not hold for module inputs or nested attributesgrokacceptBand limited to a direct argument of a resource or data block; anchors are resource or data blocks too, never a module call.
correctness 'Whatever value they pass' contradicts explicit nullgrokacceptNow 'calls that set the variable to a value other than null'.
correctness Validation, nullable and sensitive not frozengrokacceptCondition now: the diff changes nothing in the variable's block.
scope Anchor should be a resource or data block, not a module callhost agentacceptFolded into the same fix as grok's module-input point.

Why the round closed this way. codex, gemini and grok voted REQUEST_CHANGES; openrouter:glm-5-3-flashx approved. The host had approved blind but accepted all 11 issues and revised the rule again.

revision Bare var reference only (head and anchor); direct argument of a resource or data block, anchors the same; variable block unchanged; four conditions plus the null-is-unset reason; non-null callers only; example names the block.

Round 5

Blind verdict. Before any reviewer answered, the host agent recorded APPROVE: with bare references on direct resource or data block arguments the band is decidable and tight; it covers the motivating case and every looser case falls back to CRITICAL.

  • codex REQUEST CHANGESgpt-6.1-sol, 2 issues, 1m 41s

    Retain Option A after narrowing null invariance to exclude dependency effects and requiring an affirmative description promise. Effort: Short. Confidence: medium pending a dependency replay. Top risk: automatically rating a newly introduced dependency cycle LOW because all four syntactic conditions hold.
    Full response, verbatim
    **Bottom line:** Keep Option A, but revise two predicates before approval. The four conditions establish value forwarding; they do not establish dependency equivalence or that a description promises the newly added behavior.
    
    **Action plan:**
    
    1. Narrow the invariance statement to omitted inputs and literal `null` inputs. Explicitly retain ordinary severity treatment for dependency cycles introduced by the new reference.
    2. Require the description arm to positively state that this input controls this argument on the named block. A mention, exclusion or conditional promise is insufficient.
    3. Add negative regression cases for both gaps alongside the default-null mutation guard.
    
    **Effort:** Short (1-4h).  
    **Confidence:** Medium: the description counterexample is textual; the dependency counterexample follows documented graph semantics but was not executed.
    
    The dependency counterexample is a caller passing `module.example.null_output` into the input, where that output has `value = null` and `depends_on = [data.example.target]`. At base, the target does not reference the input, and an independent anchor can already consume it. At head, forwarding the input to the target closes a dependency cycle despite the expression's null value. Terraform infers dependencies from references, and outputs can carry explicit dependencies. This is an inference from those documented rules, not an observed replay. [References and dependencies](https://developer.hashicorp.com/terraform/language/expressions/references#named-values-and-dependencies), [output dependencies](https://developer.hashicorp.com/terraform/language/block/output#depends_on).
    
    The description counterexample is simpler: `"This input does not affect data.example.target"` names the full address and therefore satisfies condition 4 as written. The later assertion that the description “promised” the effect conflicts with that mechanically sufficient condition.
    
    <SUMMARY>
    Retain Option A after narrowing null invariance to exclude dependency effects and requiring an affirmative description promise. Effort: Short. Confidence: medium pending a dependency replay. Top risk: automatically rating a newly introduced dependency cycle LOW because all four syntactic conditions hold.
    </SUMMARY>
    
    VERDICT: REQUEST_CHANGES
    - [correctness] Null-as-unset proves argument-value equivalence, not dependency-graph equivalence. A null-valued module output depending on the target can form a new cycle when forwarded to it. Narrow the guarantee and keep dependency-cycle failures outside this automatic LOW band.
    - [ambiguity] Condition 4 accepts descriptions that merely name the full address, including explicit exclusions. Require an affirmative promise that this variable controls this argument on that block, preserving any stated qualifications.
  • gemini APPROVEgemini-3.8-flash-high, 0 issues, 3m 00s

    Bottom line: The Option A ignored-input LOW band for compat.expression-behaviour-changed is architecturally sound, preserving default invariance while preventing false CRITICAL blocks on input propagation. Effort: Quick (<1h). Confidence: high. Top risk: Callers explicitly passing non-null values will observe plan differences (including potential resource recreation or deferred data source reads), which is mitigated by requiring explicit release notes and summary disclosure.
    Full response, verbatim
    ### Essential
    
    - **Bottom line**: The proposed Option A plan for the "ignored-input" LOW band of `compat.expression-behaviour-changed` is architecturally sound and ready for adoption. It guarantees default invariance via Terraform's language rule (`null` equals unset for direct arguments), keeps verification decidable and fail-closed, and resolves false-positive CRITICAL blocks (such as `terraform-aws-eventbridge#212`) without touching the ladder or claim rules.
    - **Action plan**:
      1. Add the ignored-input LOW band text to the Severity section of `check-g-behaviour.md`, positioned immediately before the CRITICAL band.
      2. Add the worked example ("A Region Now Passed to a Data Source: eventbridge#212") immediately after the subnet-ids example in `check-g-behaviour.md`.
      3. Add the exact new sentences of `check-g-behaviour.md` as `+` entries in `tests/reviewer-index-sentences.txt`.
      4. Add the regression check and the `default-null` mutation refusal to `tests/reviewer-index-test.sh`.
      5. Run `tests/reviewer-index-test.sh` and `tests/skills-test.sh` to confirm sentence multiset balance and mutation coverage.
    - **Effort**: Quick (<1h).
    - **Confidence**: High.
    
    ---
    
    ### Expanded
    
    - **Why this approach**:
      1. **Strict default invariance**: Because Terraform core treats a direct argument set to `null` as unset, callers omitting the variable or passing `null` get bitwise identical plan behavior across revisions.
      2. **Syntactically bounded**: Restricting head and anchor expressions strictly to bare `var.<name>` references eliminates expression side effects (such as non-null fallbacks in `coalesce` or ternaries) that could violate null equivalence.
      3. **Decidable and fail-closed**: Conditions rely solely on base/head AST diffs and explicit base descriptions; any violation defaults directly to the existing CRITICAL/HIGH bands.
      4. **Minimal blast radius**: Reuses the existing rule structure and severity hierarchy without altering claim rules (`compat.claim-contradicts-analysis`) or ladder evaluation logic.
    
    - **Risks**:
      1. **Plan differences on non-null inputs**: Callers passing an explicit non-null value may see plan changes (such as in-place updates or data source query shifts); mitigated by requiring a release note prompt and detailing the affected address in the finding summary.
      2. **Deferred data source reads**: Passing an unknown value shifts data source reads to the apply phase; mitigated by explicitly enumerating deferred reads in the rule summary template.
      3. **Sentence record drift**: Punctuation or whitespace mismatches between `check-g-behaviour.md` and `tests/reviewer-index-sentences.txt` will break tests; mitigated by extracting sentences directly from the rendered markdown.
    
    ---
    
    ### Edge cases
    
    - **Escalation triggers**:
      1. If contributors request supporting wrapped expressions (e.g., `coalesce(var.x, default)`), escalate to a separate migration band rather than loosening the bare-reference constraint of this LOW band.
      2. If propagation across child module calls is requested, escalate to inter-module dataflow analysis.
    - **Alternative sketch**:
      Full inter-procedural dataflow modeling that traces variable expressions through child module boundaries and dynamic blocks, requiring dedicated engine parser changes rather than markdown rule refinement.
    
    <SUMMARY>
    Bottom line: The Option A ignored-input LOW band for compat.expression-behaviour-changed is architecturally sound, preserving default invariance while preventing false CRITICAL blocks on input propagation.
    Effort: Quick (<1h).
    Confidence: high.
    Top risk: Callers explicitly passing non-null values will observe plan differences (including potential resource recreation or deferred data source reads), which is mitigated by requiring explicit release notes and summary disclosure.
    </SUMMARY>
    
    VERDICT: APPROVE
  • grok REQUEST CHANGESgrok-4.7, 4 issues, 7m 17s

    This reply has no summary line. The full response is below.

    Full response, verbatim
    The ignored-input band is still the right call, but the rule text can under-rate or cannot be applied as written. Condition 1 does not actually require both expansion meta-arguments to be unchanged, and condition 4 does not constrain the anchor to a direct argument. The effect sentence also asserts more than those checks show.
    
    1. Rewrite condition 1 so `count` and `for_each` must each be absent at both revisions or identical in source text (no whitespace folding). Both absent passes. Any change in either one fails the band.
    2. In condition 4, require the anchor to be a direct argument of another resource or data block in this module, not a nested block and not a module input.
    3. Replace the effect sentence with the checked fact only: a non-null caller now passes the variable into this argument, which the base already passed with a bare reference on the anchor, or which the base description promised for this block. Do not claim the plan effect is the same.
    4. Require the deferred plan-to-apply read only when the changed block is a data source, and use that wording in the eventbridge example summary.
    5. Keep the band before CRITICAL, the null-is-unset reason, the release-note ask, and the sentence-multiset pins.
    
    Effort: Short. Confidence: high.
    
    VERDICT: REQUEST_CHANGES
    - [correctness] Condition 1's "same count or for_each" is a disjunction and does not define equality: a for_each change still passes when count is absent at both, and a block that uses neither meta-argument may fail the band. Require both to be unchanged between base and head, each absent in both revisions or the same source text in both with no whitespace folding, and treat both-absent as a pass.
    - [correctness] Condition 4 does not require the anchor assignment to be a direct argument, so a nested-block argument or a module input can anchor the band. Require a direct argument on another resource or data block of this module, with the same nested-block and module-input exclusion as the changed argument.
    - [correctness] The claim that non-null callers get the effect the base already gave on the anchor, or the effect the description promised, is not established by condition 4: the anchor need not be instantiated for those calls, be the same type, or use the argument with the same meaning. State only the checked fact, and do not claim the plan effect is the same.
    - [ambiguity] The summary rule always requires mention of a data-source read that an unknown value moves to apply, but the worked example omits it and the clause is wrong for a resource argument. Require that sentence only when the changed block is a data source, and include it in the example summary.
  • or:glm-5-3-flashx APPROVEz-ai/glm-5.3-flashx, 0 issues, 16s

    This reply has no summary line. The full response is below.

    Full response, verbatim
    Review of round 5 plan:
    
    **Correctness of the guarantee**: The four conditions now close the known holes. Condition 1 (block exists at base, same count/for_each), condition 2 (variable block untouched, default null), condition 3 (base absent/null → head bare reference), condition 4 (base anchor with the bare reference on another block, or description promising module-wide applicability) together establish: a call leaving the variable unset/null plans identically at both revisions for this argument (null-is-unset is a Terraform language rule for direct arguments, not a provider fact); a call setting the variable to non-null gives the argument the value the anchor already had at base. The narrowing to non-null callers resolves the explicit-unknown concern from round 2, and the bare-reference rule removes all expression-comparison judgment from the check — everything is textual and diff-readable.
    
    **Scope**: Same-module anchors only, direct arguments only, band rates one argument with other changes judged under their own rules, no ladder/claim changes. Correctly contained.
    
    **Regression guard**: Sentence-multiset update named, mutation test for the default-null clause. Adequate.
    
    **Security**: All inputs come from base/head code and base description; nothing from PR text. Private-repo hygiene unaffected.
    
    **Residual minor (non-blocking)**: The summary wording "as the module's resources already did" could be stale if the anchor block is itself removed in the diff — but the band's per-argument claim stays true, and the removal is separately judged. Not worth another cycle; a one-line "or the anchor's current state at head" softener is optional.
    
    **Performance**: Textual conditions only, no extra plan data required.
    
    The band decidable, conditions checkable from code, worked example grounds it, negative test mutation guards the weakest clause.
    
    VERDICT: APPROVE
    
    Optional (non-critical): consider wording the summary so it does not assert the anchor block still exists at head, in case the diff removes it — its removal is already judged under its own rule.
Round 5 rulings: every issue, with the reason the host agent wrote
IssueRaised byRulingReason
correctness Null-as-unset proves value equivalence, not dependency-graph equivalence; a new cycle can formcodexdeferA new cycle fails terraform validate or plan, which the verify and plan passes report as their own findings; the band text will say it rates the value change only and a cycle or plan error is judged on its own.
ambiguity Description arm must be an affirmative promise, not a mention of the addresscodexacceptDescription must say the variable sets this argument on this block, or on every resource and data source; a mention or an exclusion does not count.
correctness 'Same count or for_each' is a disjunction; require both unchangedgrokacceptcount and for_each each unchanged, absent in both or the same text.
correctness Anchor must be a direct argument toogrokacceptAnchor is a direct argument of another resource or data block, same exclusions.
correctness Do not claim the plan effect equals the anchor'sgrokacceptState only the checked fact: the variable now reaches this argument as it already reached the anchor or as the description says.
ambiguity Deferred data read sentence only for data sources, and in the examplegrokacceptClause applies when the block is a data source; example summary includes it.

Why the round closed this way. codex and grok voted REQUEST_CHANGES; gemini and openrouter:glm-5-3-flashx approved. The host accepted 5 issues and deferred 1, but round 5 was the cap, so the loop ended unresolved with a revision that no reviewer saw.

revision count and for_each each unchanged; anchor a direct argument; description must affirmatively promise the argument; effect claim limited to the checked fact; data-source clause only for data blocks and in the example; cycles and plan errors judged on their own.

Outcome

UNRESOLVED after 5 round(s)

Still in the report

What the run did not fix stays listed.

Type to search the site.